For a limited time only, buy a new home with a 30-Year Fixed Mortgage

4.5% Rate* / 4.5429% APR*

Tamarack Model Exterior
Model Interior
Tamarack Model Exterior
Tamarack Entrance
Tamarack Aerial
Cicero, Indiana

Tamarack

Single Family Homes in Cicero, Indiana
26 Verdant Drive, Cicero, Indiana 46034
Priced from: $326,990 Estimate Your Monthly Payment

Stunning Homes for Sale in Historic Cicero, Indiana

Welcome to Tamarack, one of M/I Homes’ newest communities on Indy’s Northside. These new homes in Cicero, Indiana offer our easy-living villas as well as our Smart Series with optional partial and full basements, set on this 250-home development.

These new homes for sale in Cicero, Indiana are set on 112 acres against a backdrop of majestic trees, natural wildlife, and beautiful views just minutes from Morse Reservoir.

As you drive through the monumental entry down gently curving streets, you can't help but be smitten by the serene ponds, recreational paths, well-maintained sidewalks, the playground, and the beautiful pool and clubhouse that you and your children or grandkids can enjoy together.

Cicero Has USDA Eligible Homes for Sale

Our Tamarack community in Cicero, Indiana is USDA-eligible, and Buyer(s) may qualify for Rural Housing Loan Programs with as little as 0% down. Visit the USDA-eligible website for more detail regarding eligibility requirements and terms.

Please contact your local M/I Financial representative for more detail regarding eligibility requirements and terms. M/I Financial, LLC (NMLS# 50684)

Energy-Efficient Homes for Sale in Cicero, Indiana

These beautiful Cicero homes for sale feature stunning, energy-efficient ranch and two-story homes designed to save you time and money. These new homes in Cicero, Indiana are designed with today's discerning buyers in mind.

  • Smart Series – Our single family homes give you the luxury you’ve always wanted and the ability to choose between a ranch or two-story home. These homes feature optional partial or full basement options with spacious, open, and flowing living spaces; amazing and functional baths and kitchens; energy-efficient building methods; and a process designed to keep you informed and engaged. These new homes in Cicero, Indiana provide affordability without sacrificing quality.

  • Villa Series – These one-story paired villa homes will offer you peace of mind with our easy, low-maintenance living complete with lawn care and snow removal. Our custom-feel villa homes in Cicero feature craftsman, traditional, and farmhouse styles with options to add unique structural features such as a second-level bonus room, perfect for guests or grandchildren to play. You can spend more time enjoying your home without worrying about mowing the grass or shoveling the snow. Enjoy your life to the fullest in Tamarack!

Cicero Homes for Sale in the Hamilton Heights School District

Living in our new homes for sale in Cicero, Indiana your children will attend and receive an education within Hamilton Heights School Corporation, where teachers work on creating a fun and safe environment to improve kids' monitoring skills and expand their learning.

Hamilton Heights Elementary School, Hamilton Heights Middle School, and Hamilton Heights High School are the schools the children of Tamarack will attend. Hamilton Heights School Corporation is located in Arcadia, IN with over 2,300 students in PK and K-12.

Things to Do in Cicero, Indiana

Our new construction homes for sale in Cicero, Indiana have everything to offer when it comes to small-town charm. These new homes are only minutes away from entertainment and outdoor recreation—take a short bike ride or walk and you can enjoy that beautiful lake life you have always wanted!

Whether it's enjoying an evening dinner at the Boathouse Kitchen & Swan Dive or hitting the links at Bear Slide Golf Club, the entertainment is never-ending.

These Cicero homes for sale are close to Morse Reservoir, Red Bridge Park, Morse Park and Beach, and Downtown Cicero, offering residents the opportunity to slow down and enjoy the great outdoors. You can even partake in delicious dining and local shopping in Downtown Cicero.

Whether you are enjoying family time at the local parks, spending the day on Morse Reservoir, or simply delighting in the small-town charm just minutes away from Tamarack, you're sure to love living here.

Location Is Everything for Our Cicero Homes for Sale

Tamarack is conveniently located near 236th Street and Tollgate Road. The community offers easy access to U.S. 31 and everything Indianapolis has to offer. Located just minutes away from Noblesville and Kokomo, and about 45 minutes from Downtown Indianapolis, this charming and proud community is waiting to welcome you home to Cicero, Indiana.

Learn more about our Cicero homes for sale by visiting Tamarack today!

Overview

City
Cicero
County
Hamilton
School District
Hamilton Heights School Corp
Community Status
Now Selling
Home Type
Single Family Homes
Sq. Footage
1,603 - 3,119

From Indianapolis: Head North Keystone Avenue to North Meridian St. until you arrive to E. 236th Street Exit. Take a right and follow E. 236th St. 4.9 miles and arrive in Tamarack on the right hand side at 236/Tollgate Rd.

Same for Heading South from Kokomo. Take a left on E. 236th St. and go 4.9 miles and arrive in Tamarack on the right hand side at 236/Tollgate Rd.

If using GPS device use this address: 236th and Southeast corner of Tollgate Rd. Cicero, Indiana

The home plan that's right for you

The following plans can be personalized for you and built in this community.

Findlay Slab Plan

in Tamarack | Cicero, Indiana

Starting at $326,990

Bed 4

Bath 3

Garage 2 - 3

Sq Ft 2,315 - 2,359

Series Smart Series

McKinley Slab Plan

in Tamarack | Cicero, Indiana

Starting at $332,990

Bed 3 - 4

Bath 3

Garage 2 - 3

Sq Ft 2,429 - 2,637

Series Smart Series

Holcomb Slab Plan

in Tamarack | Cicero, Indiana

Starting at $339,990

Bed 4 - 5

Bath 3

Garage 2 - 3

Sq Ft 2,589 - 2,745

Series Smart Series

Mackey Slab Plan

in Tamarack | Cicero, Indiana

Starting at $344,990

Bed 3

Bath 2 - 3

Garage 2 - 3

Sq Ft 1,603 - 2,110

Series Smart Series

Chauncey Slab Plan

in Tamarack | Cicero, Indiana

Starting at $347,990

Bed 4 - 5

Bath 3

Garage 2 - 3

Sq Ft 2,752 - 2,927

Series Smart Series

Plan McKinley Slab - D

School District Hamilton Heights School Corp

Estimated Move in Date 10/31/2022

Bed 3

Bath 3

Garage 3

Sq Ft 2,449

Homesite 198

Series Smart Series

Plan McKinley Slab - C

School District Hamilton Heights School Corp

Estimated Move in Date Ready Now

Bed 4

Bath 3

Garage 3

Sq Ft 2,447

Homesite 212

Series Smart Series

Plan Chauncey Slab - B

School District Hamilton Heights School Corp

Estimated Move in Date 1/31/2023

Bed 4

Bath 3

Garage 3

Sq Ft 2,773

Homesite 192

Series Smart Series

Plan Holcomb Slab - C

School District Hamilton Heights School Corp

Bed 4

Bath 3

Garage 2 ½

Sq Ft 2,620

Homesite 201

Series Smart Series

Plan Chauncey Slab - C

School District Hamilton Heights School Corp

Estimated Move in Date 1/31/2023

Bed 4

Bath 3

Garage 3

Sq Ft 2,782

Homesite 199

Series Smart Series

Bella Vista - A1 Plan

75 Perlican Drive, Cicero, IN

in Tamarack

Bed 2

Bath 2

Garage 2

Sq Ft 1,482

Homesite 4201

Castello - B2 Plan

85 Perlican Drive, Cicero, IN

in Tamarack

Bed 3

Bath 4

Garage 2

Sq Ft 2,252

Homesite 4202

Holcomb Slab - C Plan

26 Verdant Drive, Cicero, IN

in Tamarack

Bed 4

Bath 3

Garage 3

Sq Ft 2,601

Homesite 26

Series Smart Series

See These New Homes in Cicero, Indiana

Take the aerial tour!

Surrounding Area

New Homes in Historic Cicero, Indiana

Our new homes for sale are built in the historic town of Cicero, Indiana. The town was founded in 1834 and took off with the growth of flour mills, railroads, steam sawmills, and the natural gas industry. The Red Bridge, built in 1870, was turned into Red Bridge Park, offering walking paths, a pool, playground equipment, and outdoor restroom facilities. Cicero also surrounds Morse Reservoir, an expansive body of water that is fun for the whole family!

Learn More
Wildwood 65's Narrative Block 3

Enjoy Riding Your Golf Cart in Downtown Cicero, Indiana

Bear Slide Golf Course, just minutes from our new homes for sale in Cicero, offers a Scottish-links-style front nine and traditional back nine and was named one of the best nine courses in Indiana, receiving a 4.5-star rating from Golf Digest. These new homes for sale put you close to all of the golfing action!

Plan a visit
Cicero

Small-Town Charm Loaded With Cicero Fan Favorites

These new homes are just minutes away from local eateries, shops, and fun experiences. Enjoy a sweet treat at Alexander’s on the Water with some old-fashioned ice cream, grab a warm cup of joe at the Cicero Coffee Company, or enjoy dinner with a view at the Boathouse Kitchen & Swan Dive.

Learn more
Trails

Cicero’s Hidden Gem of County Parks

Are you an avid biker/hiker? Tamarack is perfect for you because it is conveniently located near USBR35 and Strawtown Koteewi Park. The park is 750-acre park with a canoe launch on the White River, nature and equestrian trails, and breathtaking wetlands and prairies. USBR35 is the Indiana Bike Route that covers 360 miles of roads and paved pathways for avid bikers.

Learn more
Construction

Put Your Mind at Ease With M/I Homes' Industry Leading Warranty

Built for maximum energy efficiency, every new M/I Home in our Cicero community is backed by our 10-Year Transferable Structural Warranty. That's the real M/I difference with our Cicero homes for sale.

Why M/I
Exterior

Smart Series Homes for Sale in Cicero, Indiana

Our new development of Cicero new homes for sale offers great choices and better value. We simplify the design process and provide flexible payment options while maintaining every home's integrity and style.

Smart Series

Become a part of this community

See what lots are available for you to begin building the home of your dreams

  • Speech Bubble
    Gloria B., Happy Homeowner Cicero, Indiana

    Our overall experience with M/I Homes was very positive for us. Right from our first encounter with representatives of M/I, we appreciated the kind attention to all our questions and potential concerns. We were always treated with respect and friendliness.

    Thanks M/I Homes! It's been a fun experience! We truly love our new home and look forward to seeing this neighborhood continue to blossom! Welcome neighbors!

  • Home
    Andrew G., Happy Homeowner Indianapolis, Indiana

    Happy with the overall process, but particularly appreciated working with the M/I Homes team. Our new home consultant and construction manager were both great to work with.

  • Home
    Kelsey, Happy Homeowner Cicero, Indiana

    M/I Homes has been great to work with on building my home. Everyone I have worked with has been polite and very communicative throughout the entire process. I would happily build again with M/I if i ever move from my new home!"

  • Star
    Sherri, Happy Homeowner Cicero, Indiana

    M/I Homes is very organized, great at communication, has a high standard of excellence, and care about their customers. I'm so thankful for this company!

  • Testimonial
    Amy H., Happy Homeowner Cicero, Indiana

    M/I Homes was an excellent builder from start to finish. The website is easy to navigate and has lots of detailed information. It was easy to find what I was looking for. The sales staff and construction manager were excellent as well.

  • Speech Bubble
    Tracy F., Happy Homeowner Cicero, Indiana
    M/I Homes built me a quality home. They follow through on their promises, take a lot of the uncertainty out of the process, and make the new construction of the home at the end a worthwhile experience. I would recommend M/I Homes to someone else.
  • Speech Bubble
    Jordan G., Happy Homeowner Cicero, Indiana
    M/I Homes made us feel comfortable throughout an otherwise stressful process during stressful times. The service was amazing and we couldn’t be happier to have chose M/I Homes as a builder.

Discover the neighborhood and all it has to offer

Discover what’s around the community, plan your commute, and find the perfect dinner spot.

NoTag
Downtown Indianapolis
41.4 miles away (about a 47 minute drive)
NoTag
Indianapolis International Airport
46.4 miles away (about a 50 minute drive)
NoTag
Children's Museum of Indianapolis
28.4 miles away (about a 42 minute drive)

Ready to plan a visit? We can help

Send us your preferred time to stop by and a sales representative will take care of the rest

Privacy Policy

Thank You

Create an account in 30 seconds

Save your favorite communities, homes, and searches to help you find the home of your dreams. All you need is a password.

Password must be at least 8 characters and contain at least 3 of these character types.

Explore Similar Communities